We will be comparing 5 Popular Git-based CMS that can be worked with your NextJS Project.
Core Features Comparison
| Feature | DecapCMS | TinaCMS | SveltiaCMS | KeystaticCMS | OutstaticCMS |
| Framework Support | Framework agnostic | React-focused | Svelte-focused | React-focused | Next.js focused |
| Open Source | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosting | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Git Provider Support | GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket | GitHub, GitLab | GitHub | GitHub | GitHub |
| Real-time Preview | Limited | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Authentication | Git providers, Custom | Git providers, Custom | GitHub | GitHub | GitHub, Auth.js |
Technical Aspects
| Aspect | DecapCMS | TinaCMS | SveltiaCMS | KeystaticCMS | OutstaticCMS |
| Setup Complexity | Low | Medium | Medium | Low | Low |
| Content Format | Markdown, YAML | Markdown, JSON | Markdown | Markdown, YAML | Markdown |
| TypeScript Support | Partial | Full | Yes | Full | Full |
| Local Development | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| API Type | REST | GraphQL | REST | REST | REST |
| Media Handling | Built-in | Built-in | Git-based | Built-in | Built-in |
User Experience
| Feature | DecapCMS | TinaCMS | SveltiaCMS | KeystaticCMS | OutstaticCMS |
| Interface Style | Traditional CMS | Visual editor | Traditional CMS | Modern minimal | Modern minimal |
| Learning Curve | Low | Medium | Medium | Low | Low |
| Content Editing | Form-based | Visual + Form | Form-based | Form-based | Form-based |
| Documentation | Extensive | Good | Basic | Good | Basic |
| Community Size | Large | Medium | Small | Growing | Small |
Use Cases & Best Fits
| CMS | Best For | Not Ideal For |
| DecapCMS | • Simple sites • Documentation • Multi-framework projects | • Complex workflows • Large teams |
| TinaCMS | • React projects • Visual editing needs • Complex content structures | • Non-React projects • Simple blogs |
| SveltiaCMS | • Svelte projects • Simple content management • Quick setup | • Large applications • Complex workflows |
| KeystaticCMS | • React/Next.js projects • Developer-first approach • Type-safe content | • Non-React projects • Complex visual editing |
| OutstaticCMS | • Next.js projects • Simple content needs • Quick setup | • Complex applications • Non-Next.js projects |
Deployment & Hosting
| Aspect | DecapCMS | TinaCMS | SveltiaCMS | KeystaticCMS | OutstaticCMS |
| Deployment Options | Any static host | Vercel, Netlify, Any | Any static host | Vercel, Any | Vercel focused |
| Build Process | Simple | Medium | Simple | Simple | Simple |
| CI/CD Integration | Easy | Medium | Easy | Easy | Easy |
| Hosting Costs | Free | Free-Premium | Free | Free | Free |
Unique Strengths
| CMS | Key Advantages |
| DecapCMS | • Most mature and stable • Large community • Framework agnostic • Extensive documentation |
| TinaCMS | • Rich visual editing • Strong React integration • Flexible content modeling • Good developer experience |
| SveltiaCMS | • Svelte-native experience • Lightweight • Simple setup • Good performance |
| KeystaticCMS | • Type-safe content • Modern DX • Good React integration • Local-first approach |
| OutstaticCMS | • Next.js optimized • Simple setup • Good Auth.js integration • Modern interface |
Recent Updates & Development
| CMS | Activity Level | Latest Features | Future Roadmap |
| DecapCMS | Active | • Improved UI • Better TypeScript support | Stable maintenance |
| TinaCMS | Very Active | • Visual editing improvements • Better MDX support | Rich editing features |
| SveltiaCMS | Moderate | • SvelteKit support • Improved auth | Growing feature set |
| KeystaticCMS | Very Active | • Enhanced type safety • Better previews | Expanding ecosystem |
| OutstaticCMS | Active | • App router support • Enhanced UI | Next.js features |
